FertileThoughts.com - Infertility, adoption, pregnancy and parenting discussions

View RSS Feed

clar

my thoughts on the Vick situation!

Rate this Entry
by , 07-29-2007 at 08:47 AM (267 Views)
I have such mixed feelings about posting this, but it is eating me up. I am a black female. Furthermore, I grew up in very rural area. There are several points that make this issue not as big as everyone wants to make it.
1)Often times when a Pro Black athlete makes it big one of the ways he gives back is to buy his love ones, friends, self real estate. It is an investment for that player that helps to elevate others. The next best status symbol to flashy jewelry and flashy cars is having houses in all these different zip codes. So Vick is not criminally liable for the activities that occurred at that house, but he is civilly liable. If you buy your kid a car. They proceed to take the car and get several speeding tickets. You know about the speeding tickets. You say to your kid...dont speed anymore. But the kid goes out is speeding again, but this time they have an accident and kill three HUMANS. Are you the parent, negligent and criminally liable?
2)In rural areas dog fighting is similar to street racing. It is something that I grew up hearing about all the time. They would bust up the dog fighting places and only charge the dog owners with drug charges and misdemeanors. So a precedent was not set that this was a serious crime as it really is. More than a racial issue, it is a class and culture issue.
3)Because some people have pets that are there pseudo children this becomes a different discussion. These same people who dearly love there pets eat pork where pigs are electrocuted to death, eat cows that are electrocuted to death so that all of their parts can be used, and chickens that are beheaded. Talk about cruel and unusual punishment. Who says which animal is more valuable than another?
What he has or has not done is wrong in general. Does it warrant the treatment that he is getting? NO. Should he be allowed to play NFL football again? YES. I am a researcher and I work to make new ways to predict the toxicity with out the excessive testing of chemicals on animals. I try to use what has already been done to make some judgments about how a new chemical might interact with the human body. To create that data that I try to now use, there were many animals lost. Is this wrong? Are these rats and mice not animals? What is the alternative? Will you step up to the plate and volunteer your body for testing? Just my thoughts. I guess it is okay to kill animals when it is convenient...for the greater good like your next meal or your next perfume.
Tags: None Add / Edit Tags
Categories
Children

Comments

  1. favresgirl's Avatar
    Killing an animal to be used to feed others is one thing, teaching animals to kill each other for the pure pleasure of others and to make money is another thing completely. And once these poor animals are rescued they can never be retrained, so most end up being put to death. It is a horrible situation all around. And yes, I am a dog lover who eats meat.
  2. FlaMom's Avatar
    i disagree that dog fighting is only a cultural issue. just because it's been done for a long time doesn't make it right. female genital mutilation is cultural too, but it is so very very wrong.

    killing for pleasure is different from killing for a purpose. i am a carnivore. do i like the way food animals are killed? no, but it does serve a purpose.

    should the NFL punish MV for these charges? no. what he's allegedly done has never had a bearing on his success on the field (as drugs or betting on games would have). should he be allowed to play? yes. unless/until a conviction is in direct violation of NFL policy. (i have no idea if it does.)
  3. GirlMom's Avatar
    No matter how you look at it, dog fighting is reprehensible and anyone involved should have to answer for it. I *hope* he is not directly involved, but it isn't looking too good for him. It's a pity... he is/was a very respected young man.

    Karen
DISCLAIMER: Fertile Thoughts allows advertisers to publish information about their services. Fertile Thoughts does not provide medical advice or endorse any particular service or approach to treating infertility. We encourage people to learn as much as possible about the range of options available before committing to any one. We also encourage users to share their thoughts on all fertility options on our forums.

Forum Stats

  • Forum Members: 69,729
  • Total Threads: 363,799
  • Total Posts: 4,683,486
There are 1665 users currently browsing forums.

Advertisement

Visit Our Partner Sites: Fertility Treatments

SEO by vBSEO